What Does Prayer Accomplish? (D. Kirk)

Daniel Kirk highlighted this significant debate from the Twitterverse the other day.  Here’s his thoughts — and I agree with him. -JB

Daniel Kirk wrote:

Yesterday in the Twitterverse the following quote was going around:

The function of prayer is not to influence God, but rather to change the nature of the one who prays.

It’s alleged that this quote comes from Kierkegaard, though I haven’t seen a reference appended to it anywhere.

The first time I saw the quote, I jumped into a good conversation about it. Then after the third time I saw it, I was done.

If I may put it provocatively: the quote is a cop out. It transforms prayer from a dangerous act in which we summon the God of all the earth to act now upon the earth over which God is sovereign into something that’s just for shaping our little hearts. This is the worst sort of existentialism working itself out in a theology of prayer. The real thing isn’t that God would be intimately involved in the real world, acting on behalf of those upon whom God has set God’s name. No, the real thing would be getting ourselves aligned with some transhistorical God who won’t be bothered to engage the lives of God’s people.

If Kierkegaard is right, Christianity is not worth believing, and prayer is not worth doing.

Ok, let me soften it a bit: it’s not “not… but…” but rather “both… and…”

Yes, in spending time with God in prayer we will be changed, hopefully conformed more to God’s image by subjecting our own will to God’s.

And, every single time in the entire Bible that we read about prayer, or see someone praying, the whole point is to invoke God to break into a world that seems to be running amok and to redirect it for God’s glory and the good of God’s people (which, incidentally, are inseparable).

When I go to the Father, Jesus says, you will ask in my name–and you will receive because I am going to the Father.

When you pray, says Jesus, ask for all this stuff: God’s name to be hallowed, God’s kingdom to come, God’s will to be done on earth, your daily bread, and forgiveness of your sins.

When Christians pray, we are asking God to act–specifying places in the world where God’s kingdom is not yet come, where God’s will is not yet done on earth as it is in heaven–to transform this world into the place that God created, and has destined it to be.

The idea that we pray only to be transformed ourselves is the profession of a defeated people. It’s the theological excuse of a people whose prayers are weak, or go unanswered. And rather than wrestle with God or continue to confess the truth about prayer as it should be, we create a theological legitimation of our own lack, of God’s own absence.

I’d rather cling to the truth in boldness, and pray for God to act.

I, Jeremy, would also hasten to want to add to this conversation the element of spiritual battle that takes place within in the spirit realm, and the powerful weapon prayer is in waging war in the spirit.  See Greg Boyd on this topic.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s